Scientific Journal ISSN 1991-0533
Complaints and Appeals
The Vestnik of Rostov State University of Economics (RINH) considers submissions from authors, reviewers, readers, and other interested parties concerning editorial decisions, compliance with peer-review procedures, publication ethics, and the conduct of participants in the editorial process.
Appeals against editorial decisions and complaints concerning editorial conduct are handled as separate procedures. Submission of an appeal or complaint does not guarantee that a previous decision will be changed, but it ensures that the matter will be considered objectively on the basis of the arguments and evidence provided.
Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
Authors may appeal a decision to reject a manuscript or another editorial decision where they believe that a substantial scholarly, factual, or procedural error occurred during manuscript evaluation.
An appeal should include:
- the title of the manuscript;
- the name and contact details of the corresponding author;
- the manuscript identifier, if one has been assigned;
- the editorial decision being appealed;
- specific grounds for requesting reconsideration;
- where appropriate, factual or documentary evidence supporting the appeal.
An author's disagreement with reviewers' comments does not in itself constitute sufficient grounds for changing an editorial decision. An appeal should identify specific scholarly or procedural grounds for reconsideration.
The Editorial Office considers the appeal in light of the original peer-review materials and the arguments submitted by the author. Where necessary, the manuscript may be referred for an additional expert assessment by a specialist who was not involved in the original peer review.
Additional peer review following an appeal is not automatic and is undertaken only where the Editorial Office considers it necessary for an objective assessment of the case.
Following consideration of an appeal, the Editorial Office may uphold the original decision, revise the decision, or refer the manuscript for additional peer review. The author is informed of the outcome.
Complaints
Complaints may concern the actions or omissions of the Editorial Office, an editor, a member of the Editorial Board, a reviewer, or another participant in the editorial process.
Grounds for a complaint may include, but are not limited to:
- failure to follow the journal's established manuscript evaluation or peer-review procedures;
- breach of confidentiality;
- an undisclosed conflict of interest;
- improper use of material from an unpublished manuscript;
- breaches of publication ethics;
- unjustified departure from the journal's published editorial policies;
- other conduct that may call into question the objectivity or integrity of the editorial process.
A complaint should provide a specific description of the circumstances concerned and, where available, documents or other information that may assist in verifying the facts.
Handling of Complaints
A complaint must not be handled by the person whose conduct is the subject of the complaint. Where a conflict of interest exists, consideration of the complaint is assigned to another member of the Editorial Board or another authorised person who is not involved in the matter.
Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the Editor-in-Chief does not participate in its consideration. The matter is referred to the journal's publisher, Rostov State University of Economics (RINH), for consideration by an authorised person who is not involved in the subject of the complaint.
In examining a complaint, the Editorial Office may request explanations and supporting materials from authors, reviewers, editors, or other persons connected with the circumstances under consideration.
The complainant is informed of the outcome of the review. Where a breach of editorial or publication procedures is established, the journal takes appropriate measures to address it, including correction of published information, reconsideration of an editorial decision, or application of the procedures established in the journal's corrections and retractions policy.
Confidentiality
Complaints and appeals are handled confidentially to the extent necessary for an objective examination of the circumstances. The identity of the complainant and the materials submitted are not disclosed to persons who are not involved in considering the case, except where disclosure is necessary to establish the facts or is required by law.
Submission of a complaint or appeal must not in itself result in adverse treatment of an author, reviewer, or other complainant in the evaluation of current or future manuscripts.
Submitting a Complaint or Appeal
Complaints and appeals should be submitted to the Editorial Office by email: vestnik.rsue@mail.ru or vestnic.rsue@mail.ru.
The subject line should preferably include “Appeal” or “Complaint”. Where the matter concerns a particular manuscript or published article, its title should also be provided.
Complaints and appeals are considered in accordance with the principles of publication ethics and with due regard to the independence, objectivity, and confidentiality of the editorial process.