Peer Review

All research articles that fall within the scope of Vestnik of Rostov State University of Economics (RINH) and comply with the mandatory submission requirements undergo independent scholarly peer review.

The Journal applies double-anonymous peer review (double-blind peer review): the identity of the reviewer is not disclosed to the author, and information directly identifying the author is not provided to the reviewer.

Peer review is intended to provide an independent assessment of the scholarly quality of a manuscript, the validity of its methodology, the reliability of its results and its relationship to the current state of research in the relevant field.

1. Initial Editorial Screening

Before being sent for scholarly peer review, each manuscript undergoes initial editorial screening.

The Editorial Office checks:

  • whether the manuscript falls within the aims and scope of the Journal;
  • whether the submitted materials are complete;
  • compliance with the mandatory structural and formatting requirements;
  • the presence and consistency of required information and metadata;
  • the presence of inappropriate textual borrowing;
  • any circumstances that prevent the manuscript from being sent for scholarly peer review.

Originality screening is part of initial editorial control but does not replace scholarly peer review or substantive assessment of a manuscript.

If a manuscript falls outside the Journal’s scope, does not meet mandatory requirements or is submitted without the required materials, the Editorial Office may return it to the author before peer review, stating the reasons.

The submission procedure and initial editorial screening are described in the Manuscript Submission and Review Procedure.

2. Preparation of the Manuscript for Peer Review

Before a manuscript is sent to a reviewer, the Editorial Office prepares an anonymised version. The materials submitted for scholarly evaluation do not contain author names, institutional affiliations, contact details or other direct identifying information.

The reviewer’s identity is not disclosed to the author. Reviewers must not take steps intended to establish the identity of the author.

A reviewer’s supposition concerning possible authorship based on the content of the manuscript must not in itself affect the scholarly assessment.

3. Selection of Reviewers

A manuscript is sent to one or, where necessary, more than one reviewer depending on the subject matter, interdisciplinary nature of the study and complexity of the scholarly assessment required.

Members of the Editorial Board and external experts may serve as reviewers.

Each reviewer must be a qualified specialist in the subject area of the manuscript and must have scholarly publications relevant to the topic of the manuscript within the previous three years.

When selecting a reviewer, the Editorial Office considers the reviewer’s scholarly competence and any information available to the Editorial Office concerning circumstances that may reasonably call into question the independence of the assessment.

Membership of the Editorial Board does not in itself constitute grounds for appointment as a reviewer and does not replace the requirement for appropriate scholarly expertise.

4. Requirements for Reviewers

Reviewers must assess manuscripts objectively, in good faith and within the limits of their professional competence.

If a reviewer believes that their expertise is insufficient for a proper evaluation of the study, or cannot complete the review within the agreed period, the reviewer must inform the Editorial Office.

Reviewers must not contact authors directly. All questions, comments and recommendations are communicated through the Editorial Office.

No other person may be involved in the preparation of a review without the prior approval of the Editorial Office.

If, during the review process, the reviewer becomes aware of circumstances that may reasonably call into question the independence or objectivity of the assessment, the reviewer must inform the Editorial Office and suspend the review pending an editorial decision.

5. Criteria for Scholarly Assessment

In preparing a report, the reviewer evaluates the scholarly content of the manuscript with due regard to the nature and methodology of the particular study.

The scholarly assessment includes consideration of:

  • the clarity of the research problem and research objective;
  • the relevance of the research problem and the extent to which it has previously been studied;
  • the quality of the review of current scholarly literature and the positioning of the study in relation to previous research;
  • the validity of the methodological approach, methods and research procedures;
  • the quality, sufficiency and verifiability of the data and materials used;
  • the validity of the reported results and the correspondence between the conclusions and the results presented;
  • the scholarly originality and theoretical and/or practical significance of the findings;
  • the quality of interpretation and discussion of the results, including comparison with previously published research;
  • the accuracy of concepts, definitions, calculations, tables, figures and other forms of presenting results;
  • the quality of scholarly argumentation and the overall logic of the manuscript;
  • any significant limitations that should be taken into account when interpreting the results.

For theoretical and methodological studies, these criteria are applied with regard to the nature of the research and do not require empirical data or a structure that is inappropriate to the study.

Formal manuscript formatting, completeness of author information, the presence of required metadata and originality-screening results are matters for editorial control and are not the primary responsibility of the scholarly reviewer.

6. Content and Outcome of the Review

A review must provide a reasoned assessment of the scholarly strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript. Comments must be specific, professional and sufficiently clear to enable the author to understand the basis of the assessment and the revisions required.

A review must not contain derogatory, offensive or irrelevant comments.

Reviewers should draw the Editorial Office’s attention to substantial similarities between the manuscript and published work known to them, suspected inappropriate borrowing, potentially unreliable data or other circumstances that may be relevant to the editorial decision.

At the conclusion of the assessment, the reviewer makes one of the following recommendations:

  • recommend publication in the submitted form;
  • recommend publication after the specified revisions without mandatory further peer review;
  • request substantial revision followed by another round of peer review;
  • do not recommend publication, with the scholarly grounds for this recommendation clearly stated.

The reviewer’s recommendation is an important part of the editorial procedure but does not replace the final editorial decision.

7. Communication of Reviews and Manuscript Revision

The author receives an anonymised copy of the review and, where necessary, additional editorial comments. Information capable of identifying the reviewer is not disclosed to the author.

Where revision is required, the author submits a revised manuscript together with a response to the comments indicating how each point has been addressed.

The author may provide a reasoned scholarly explanation for disagreeing with an individual reviewer comment.

Disagreement with a reviewer comment does not in itself constitute grounds for rejection. The Editorial Office assesses the reasoning provided by the author and whether issues material to the reliability and scholarly quality of the study have been adequately addressed.

The deadline for submitting a revised manuscript is stated in the editorial communication and is normally up to one month. Where necessary, another deadline may be agreed with the author.

If the author does not submit the revised manuscript and does not contact the Editorial Office regarding an extension, consideration of the manuscript may be discontinued.

8. Repeat and Additional Peer Review

If a manuscript has undergone substantial revision following peer review, the Editorial Office may send it for another round of scholarly evaluation.

The revised manuscript may be assessed by the original reviewer or by another specialist who meets the Journal’s reviewer requirements.

Where expert opinions differ substantially, where different aspects of an interdisciplinary study require additional expertise, or where there are reasonable grounds to consider the existing assessment insufficient, the Editorial Office may appoint an additional reviewer.

The number of positive or negative recommendations does not by itself replace substantive consideration of the review reports. Editorial decisions take into account the reviewers’ reasoning and the scholarly basis of their recommendations.

9. Editorial Decision

The final decision concerning a manuscript is made by the Editorial Office.

The decision takes into account:

  • the manuscript’s relevance to the Journal’s aims and scope;
  • the scholarly quality and originality of the research;
  • the results of independent peer review;
  • the validity of reviewers’ comments and the author’s responses;
  • completion of necessary revisions;
  • compliance with publication ethics and the Journal’s other requirements.

A positive review does not automatically guarantee acceptance for publication.

A reviewer’s negative recommendation is considered by the Editorial Office in light of the scholarly reasoning provided. Additional peer review may be arranged where necessary.

Following consideration, the Editorial Office decides to accept the article for publication, request further revision or reject the manuscript. The author is informed of the decision and, where the manuscript is rejected, of the principal reasons for that decision.

The order in which manuscripts are received and the scheduling of issues may be taken into account after an article has been accepted when determining the issue in which it will appear, but they are not criteria of scholarly evaluation and do not determine whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected.

10. Confidentiality of Peer Review

A manuscript is confidential material until publication.

Reviewers must not disclose the manuscript, any part of it, data, findings or information concerning the study to third parties, discuss unpublished material outside the editorial process or use information obtained through peer review for personal advantage.

After completion of the review, manuscript materials must not be retained or used by the reviewer for personal purposes.

Unpublished manuscripts, manuscript fragments, research data, review reports or editorial correspondence must not be uploaded or transmitted to external generative artificial intelligence systems. Detailed requirements are set out in the Journal’s Artificial Intelligence Policy.

The identity of the reviewer and information capable of identifying the reviewer are not disclosed to authors or readers except where disclosure is required by law or takes place with the consent of the person concerned.

11. Peer Review Timeframes

The deadline for preparing a review is agreed between the Editorial Office and the reviewer with regard to the length, subject matter and complexity of the manuscript.

The initial cycle of editorial consideration and scholarly peer review normally does not exceed two months from the date on which the Editorial Office receives a complete set of materials meeting the Journal’s requirements.

Time taken by the author to revise the manuscript is not included in this period. Where repeat or additional peer review is required, the overall consideration period is extended by the time required for the relevant assessment.

12. Retention of Reviews and Provision of Copies

Peer-review reports are retained by the Editorial Office and the publisher for five years.

Authors are provided with anonymised copies of the reviews and/or a reasoned notification of rejection.

Upon an appropriate request, the Editorial Office provides copies of peer-review reports to the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation in accordance with the applicable procedure.

Peer-review reports are not published openly unless otherwise expressly provided for by the Journal’s editorial policy and agreed with the participants in the peer-review process.

13. Appeals Concerning Peer Review and Editorial Decisions

Authors may submit a reasoned response to a review or appeal an editorial decision where they believe that substantial scholarly or procedural errors occurred in the assessment of the manuscript.

Disagreement with a reviewer’s conclusions does not in itself constitute sufficient grounds for reconsideration. An appeal must identify specific scholarly or procedural grounds.

Where necessary, the Editorial Office may arrange an additional independent assessment.

The procedure for considering such submissions is set out in the Journal’s Complaints and Appeals Policy.

14. Ethical Principles of Peer Review

In conducting peer review, the Editorial Office and reviewers follow the principles of independence of scholarly assessment, confidentiality, integrity, professional competence and prohibition of the use of unpublished manuscript materials for personal advantage.

Conflicts of interest, research integrity, the responsibilities of participants in the publication process and procedures for addressing suspected breaches are governed by the Journal’s Publication Ethics Policy.